The Boyfriend List: Does He Meet The 12 Checkmarks?

In Love by Kristen Dalton Wolfe17 Comments


It’s so funny how we know our self worth and how we should be treated when we’re single. Then suddenly, we meet the guy that shows us some flattering attention and we’re knocked off our game. Some of those lovely ideals and standards you carried for your future boyfriend flies right out the window. And because we are in loooove now, our once 20/20 vision is blurred and the values we once held don’t seem so important anymore. Our friends hear all the justifications as to why he doesn’t need to be this or that. For example, “Oh we don’t need to share the same faith, he has a good heart.” (I used that one myself.) Or, “He doesn’t have to get along with my friends, they actually are kind of annoying. I just never saw it until now.”

Then one day, we wonder how in the world we ever got to this place with this person who isn’t at all what we imagined. Deep down, we wonder if our desires and hopes are unrealistic, if maybe the way he mistreats us is our fault, that we somehow deserve to settle.

So this list is for two reasons. First, if you’re not in a relationship yet, this serves as a framework of basic qualities to keep an eye on when you’re dating and meeting new guys. Secondly, it’s for those who are in a relationship now and are looking for some clarity on whether to move forward.

Patience: There is safety with a person who doesn’t give every single inconvenience, delay or trouble the power to upset him or ruffle his feathers. Observe how he handles things when they don’t go his way. Do you constantly have to calm him down?

Kind: Your man should notice and call out the beauty in you. You should feel gorgeous, empowered and worthy when you are with him. Depending on your love language (physical touch, words of affirmation, quality time, gift giving & acts of service), is he intentional about making sure you feel uplifted and loved in that area? For instance, my love language is quality time so it makes my heart feel so covered when my husband purposely plans out time alone just for us. It shows me that he cares and is willing to put his other priorities aside and love me in the way that I am fueled by it the most.

Encouraging: He celebrates your talents, passions, family time and friendships. He does not envy your relationships with friends or become jealous when you receive recognition. He also doesn’t try to talk you out of opportunities that are aligned with your life’s purpose. He doesn’t allow jealousy to come between you and loved ones or your dreams.

Humble: He is able to say “thank you” and “I’m sorry” quickly. Your guy can thank and acknowledge others when they help them and also can acknowledge when he has wronged you without pointing fingers and making a trail of excuses. That gets you nowhere but backwards, and probably in a more drawn out fight, causing more damage to the relationship.

Honoring: He knows your time and heart is valuable, therefore he honors his plans and commitments he makes with you. He says what he means and means what he says, and you can trust him because of this. Most importantly, he honors your family by never speaking badly about them or instigating division. Whether he likes them or not is irrelevant, it is a matter of respect and it gives you a nice preview of how he will treat you when less than perfect patches occur in a potential marriage.

Generous: He isn’t just a taker, there must be balance. You may be the kind of woman who receives her value from giving. Giving is a wonderful thing, but it can be detrimental to your soul eventually if it is taken advantage of and not reciprocated by your man. Be sure he isn’t only with you for what you give to him, but because he genuinely finds joy in giving to you as well.

Even- Tempered: He is not easily angered or at least knows how to handle his anger when he is provoked. You may not think you would ever be the victim of his temper while you’re in the dating phase, but the way he reacts to others and particularly his own family members, shows you his true character and you will deal with it eventually. If you want a family one day, imagine how he would respond when the house is messy, loud and chaotic. You want to be with a guy who will be a safe person for not only you, but future children.

He can let it go: He knows how to move forward and never holds your mistakes or embarrassing moments against you. He covers your reputation, emotions and dignity by never seeking to humiliate you.

Voice of Reason: He helps you move past conflict or difficult situations. He doesn’t fuel the fire of conflict, instead he helps offer sound perspective with logic and truth.

Protective: You know you can always count on him to defend you or stand up for you in any situation. He should always have your back, physically and emotionally.

Trusting: He doesn’t regularly accuse you of baseless actions like flirting with another guy when you didn’t even look at him. This stirs you to constantly defend yourself, which can cause you to feel crazy and even start questioning yourself. It’s psychological and a way for him to establish control. Your man should trust you and always assume the best about you.

Persistent: He fights for you, your relationship and doesn’t abandon you when conflict arises.

You become the average of the 5 people you spend the most time with, so if your boyfriend gets the biggest percentage of your time, he has a huge impact on you. That’s why it is wise to align yourself with a man who brings out the best in you, not the worst.

By the way, I’m not making this list up. The definition of love is laid out here. To check how your boyfriend is doing in the love department, replace the word, “love” with his name.

Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. Love never fails. — 1 Corinthians 13:4-8

At the end of the day, of course we all aren’t going to be all 12 of these all of the time. As wise, discerning women, we can extend grace, encouragement and compassion in weak moments. What matters is that their heart is in a place where they want to be the best version of themselves and they do what it takes to see that transpire.

Take The Pledge to get your FREE Guide to Radiating Irresistible Confidence

If this message blessed you, be a blessing by sharing with others.


  1. Beautiful article! As someone who is newly single, this will definitely help me when I get back into the dating world.

  2. This is a beautiful article and I cried at the end with inserting your BF’s name in the scripture. I’ve been married for 30 years and I can’t wait to read your other pieces. I was just introduced to your website today thru a friend on Facebook. I’ve already shared your 12 Checklist with my daughters in their 20’s. I’m excited for them to receive your daily articles. Thank you for your ministry. What a blessing!

  3. This is really beautiful and a joy to read! It definitely gave me reassurance in what I’m looking for in a relationship. My only hope is that we, as women, remember that we need to have and display these twelves traits as well. It is not only the duty of a man to be all of these things for us, but women need to do the same for the men of our lives. This may go without saying, but I do think it is important to acknowledge the ebb and flow in a relationship.

  4. Thank you Kristen for your website. I find your articles and daily post very inspirational. I never thought I would need helpful hints in the dating world but as you know I was forced into the single life last year when I lost my husband. Thank you for She is More!

    I AM MORE 😉

    Renee Girault – RMP Momma
    (Kristen Girault-LA USA 2013)

  5. Thanks for the good article, I will give this to my four single daughters for marriage advice!

  6. I think this applies to us to! So many times we focus on what we should look for in a guy and we don’t look at our own self reflection. Once you’ve prepared yourself in God… God will do the rest 🙂 Great post btw though!

  7. Beautifully put. I think this applies to everyone, not just boyfriends. Plenty of girls don’t appreciate it when guys meet these checkmarks, and plenty of guys do the same. I think the 14th, and most important checkmark, is equality in a relationship. If you expect something from him, know that he should expect it from you, and vice versa. Communication is very important too. Now I’m rambling. Thanks!

  8. This is such an inspirational article. And I believe every woman should read this. And probably even men to see the kind of man a woman wants to be with and start a life with. It’s up to both man and woman to make a relationship work, so I believe both should read 🙂 thank you for the uplifting and inspirational article. 🙂

  9. Beautifully written! As the mom to teenage boys and a teenage girl, I can relate to this article both ways. The obvious way it was intended is what a girl should look for in a boyfriend, and I pray my daughter does so, as well as that my sons are the types of young men so wonderfully described above. But I think it’s also important for girls to remember that they too should be the type of girlfriend described above, because boys (well, the ones worth waiting for anyway) are looking for girls who possess all of these characteristics as well. Thanks, and will be sharing!

  10. Pingback: Praying for your (future) husband | MiscellaneousBelle

  11. It sounded like you read my personal thoughts lol I finally get a second chance to put these values up and actually go through with them instead of telling myself it’s unrealistic to have them. I will re-read this as many times as I need a reminder of what I’m looking for.

  12. Thank you! This list describes my man perfectly even after over a year of being together. I feel beyond blessed.

  13. As a father of two daughters(and no sons), I must be a full partner in helping our daughters realize what is put here in this expanded look at the meaning behind that all-too-short passage mentioned from I Corinthians 13.

Leave a Comment